This National Pizza Month, DoorDash is fueling the ultimate pizza showdown. By analyzing thousands of customer ratings and reviews from January through September 2025, DoorDash is celebrating a list of the 50 most popular local pizzerias* drawn from five iconic pizza states: California, Connecticut, Illinois, Michigan, and New York.
Pizza has always been the original delivery hero. Long before burrito bowls and bubble tea hit our doorsteps, a hot, cheesy pie proved it could travel from oven to doorstep without losing its magic – cementing its place in history as the food built for delivery.
Celebrating Local Pizza Merchants
At DoorDash, our mission is to grow and empower local economies, and that starts with celebrating the small merchants who fuel our communities. These 50 pizzerias aren’t just places to grab a slice: they’re neighborhood anchors, family traditions, and entrepreneurial success stories. Every order fuels their growth and keeps communities connected.
“Pizza brings people together, from friends watching a game to kids celebrating a birthday. Every region and chef puts their own spin on a classic, and that creativity is what makes it so special,” said Ruth Isenstadt, Head of US Restaurants at DoorDash. “These local pizzerias help create memories around the table, and National Pizza Month is the perfect chance to enjoy your go-to favorite or try something new.”
Based on DoorDash data from January through September 2025, these pizzerias have fewer than 10 locations, at least 1,000 customer reviews, with the highest average ratings on DoorDash, and are winning the hearts and stomachs of pizza lovers nationwide.
From Golden Boy Pizza (California) with its iconic clam & garlic square pie, Fino Wood Fired Pizza Bar (Connecticut) with a hot honey slice, Happy Camper Pizza (Illinois) putting their own spin on the Hawaiian, Greco's Pizza (Michigan) for its famous BBQ chicken pizza, and Joe's Pizza (New York), a landmark institution in the pizza world, the list includes:
California
A Slice of New York Pizza – San Jose, CA
Benjis Woodfire Pizza – Citrus Heights, CA
Dimond Slice Pizza – Oakland, CA
Flour + Water Pizza Shop – San Francisco, CA
Golden Boy Pizza – San Francisco, CA
Massimo's Pizza – Huntington Beach, CA
Pizzana – Los Angeles, CA
Square Pie Guys – Oakland, CA
Tony's Pizza Napoletana – San Francisco, CA
Triple Beam Pizza – Los Angeles, CA
Connecticut
Anna's Pizza Restaurant – East Hartford, CT
Asylum Street Pizza – Norwich, CT
Est Est Est Pizza – New Haven, CT
Fino Wood Fired Pizza Bar – Watertown, CT
Hubspoke Kitchen – Wallingford, CT
Joey Garlic's – Manchester, CT
Mario's Pizzeria – Naugatuck, CT
Occum Pizza – Norwich, CT
Pietros Pizza – Hartford, CT
Sofias Pizzeria – East Windsor, CT
Illinois
Danny's Pizza And Burger Bar – Chicago, IL
Dimo's Pizza – Chicago, IL
Fire Bar and Grill – Crystal Lake, IL
Happy Camper Pizza – Chicago, IL
Jimmy's Pizza Cafe – Chicago, IL
Mazala Pizza - Moti – Chicago, IL
Pequod's Pizza – Chicago, IL
Piece Pizzeria & Brewery – Chicago, IL
Ranalli's Pizza – Chicago, IL
Robert's Pizza & Dough Company – Chicago, IL
Michigan
24th Street Pizzeria – Port Huron, MI
Bob's Pizza Palace – Detroit, MI
Bongiorno's Pizza – Flint, MI
Crispelli's Bakery and Pizzeria – Berkley, MI
Dolly's Pizza – Walled Lake, MI
Greco's Pizza – Grand Rapids, MI
Mootz Pizzeria + Bar – Detroit, MI
Roma's Pizza – Kalamazoo, MI
Table 53 Pizzeria – Warren, MI
Yaya's Pizza – Farmington, MI
New York
Brooklyn DOP – Brooklyn, NY
Cosimo's Brick Oven – Middletown
F&F Pizzeria – Brooklyn, NY
Good Guys Pizza – North Tonawanda, NY
Joe's Pizza – Manhattan, NY
One Pie Pizza – Buffalo, NY
Pizza Wizard – Rochester, NY
Rubirosa Pizza & Ristorante – Manhattan, NY
The Pizzeria – Islip, NY
Tino’s Pizzeria – Oneonta, NY
Who Wins the 2025 Pizza Showdown?
Is New York’s foldable slice the GOAT? Does Chicago’s deep dish deserve the crown? Or is Detroit-style the sleeper champ? The verdict is clear: America refuses to choose just one. From coast to coast, every region claims its slice is the best.
With more than 500,000 merchants on the DoorDash Marketplace, pizza lovers can celebrate pizza night at home however they like — thin crust, deep dish, square, or somewhere in between. Don’t see your favorite spot on this year’s list? No problem. Your perfect pie (and so much more) is just a tap away.
To celebrate National Pizza Month, check out the above pizzerias for current deals, or take advantage of these deals on DoorDash:
Godfather’s Pizza (Valid through 11/17/2025)
Spend $25, Get $8 off (DashPass members)
Spend $25, Get $7 off (non-DashPass users)
Mountain Mike’s (offer valid through 11/17/2025 on Thursday - Monday)
Spend $25, Get $8 off (DashPass members)
Spend $25, Get $7 off (non-DashPass users)
Terms apply.**
*The list of 50 Local Pizzerias for National Pizza Month 2025 was generated by analyzing DoorDash data from January 2025 through September 2025. All small-medium sized restaurants and brands with less than 10 stores, the highest average overall customer rating, and at least 1,000 reviews, qualified for this list.
** Terms & Conditions
$25, Get $8 Off (DashPass members only): Offer valid through 11/17/2025 on orders placed from participating Godfather’s Pizza locations. Must have an active DashPass account. Valid only on orders with a minimum subtotal of $25, excluding fees and taxes. If the full $8 value is not used on a single order, the remaining value will be forfeited. Not valid for pickup. Limit one per person. Not valid for the purchase of alcohol. Fees, taxes, and gratuity still apply. See full terms and conditions at https://drd.sh/8ONpZP/
$25, Get $7 off (non-DashPass users): Offer valid through 11/17/2025 on orders placed from participating Godfather’s Pizza locations. Valid only on orders with a minimum subtotal of $25, excluding fees and taxes. If the full $7 value is not used on a single order, the remaining value will be forfeited. Not valid for pickup. Limit one per person. Not valid for the purchase of alcohol. Fees, taxes, and gratuity still apply. See full terms and conditions at https://drd.sh/8ONpZP/
$25, Get $8 Off (DashPass members only): Offer valid Thursday through Monday through 11/17/2025 on orders placed at participating locations of Mountain Mike’s. Must have an active DashPass account. Valid only on orders with a minimum subtotal of $25, excluding fees and taxes. If the full $8 value is not used on a single order, the remaining value will be forfeited. Not valid for pickup. Limit one per person. Not valid for the purchase of alcohol. Fees, taxes, and gratuity still apply. See full terms and conditions at https://drd.sh/8ONpZP/
$25, Get $7 off (non-DashPass users): Offer valid Thursday through Monday from through 11/17/2025 on orders placed at participating locations of Mountain Mike’s. Valid only on orders with a minimum subtotal of $25, excluding fees and taxes. If the full $7 value is not used on a single order, the remaining value will be forfeited. Not valid for pickup. Limit one per person. Not valid for the purchase of alcohol. Fees, taxes, and gratuity still apply. See full terms and conditions at https://drd.sh/8ONpZP/
